On September 16, the House Ways and Means Committee voted 38-5 to end a tax break Bitcoin owners have had for years and stock owners lost decades ago — the right to sell at a loss, lock in the deduction, and buy the same coins right back the same minute. The bill that would end it, H.R. 10357, reaches back to any Bitcoin sold after September 14. That date was two days before the committee even voted. It is not law yet. But if you bought Bitcoin anywhere near this year’s highs and you’re sitting on a loss today, the weeks between now and December 31 may decide whether that loss is still yours to use.
| What Just Happened House Ways & Means voted 38-5 on Sept 16 for H.R. 10357. It applies the decades-old stock wash-sale rule to Bitcoin for the first time — and as written, reaches back to sales after Sept 14. |
What’s At Stake A $27,500 Bitcoin position now worth about $20,435 carries a $7,065 loss. At a 15% long-term rate, that loss is worth roughly $1,060 off this year’s tax bill — if it survives. |
The One Asset With No Issuer Dollar stablecoins are carved out of the bill entirely. Bitcoin — 21 million coins, no company behind it — is not. |
The tax break stock owners lost decades ago, and Bitcoin owners still have
The wash-sale rule has covered stocks and bonds for decades. Sell a stock at a loss, buy the same stock back within 30 days before or after the sale, and the IRS won’t let you claim that loss this year — it gets pushed onto the cost basis of your new shares instead. Congress wrote that rule to stop exactly the move it sounds like: selling purely to harvest a tax deduction while never actually leaving the position.
Bitcoin has never been covered by that rule, for one specific reason: the IRS classifies Bitcoin itself as property, not a security. Property doesn’t trigger the wash-sale rule. Stocks do. That single classification is why, today, a Bitcoin owner sitting on a loss can sell, lock in the deduction, and buy the identical amount of Bitcoin back a minute later — keeping the position and the tax break at the same time. Here’s the detail almost nobody clocks: a Bitcoin ETF on the stock market is already subject to the wash-sale rule, because fund shares are securities. Only the actual coin, held directly, kept the break. That is the specific gap H.R. 10357 is written to close.
The bill, the vote, and the date that already passed
H.R. 10357, the Digital Asset Tax Certainty Act, was introduced September 14 by House Ways and Means Chairman Jason Smith. Two days later, on September 16, his committee passed it 38-5 — every Republican on the committee voted yes, and so did twelve Democrats. The Joint Committee on Taxation, Congress’s own scorekeeper, estimates the wash-sale provision alone raises about $1.707 billion over ten years, collected specifically from people who sold digital assets at a loss.
It is not law. The House left for the November election and has not taken a floor vote. The bill still needs to pass the full House, the Senate, and be signed by the president. The Senate has its own version in play — a bill from Senator Steve Daines, backed by Cynthia Lummis, Tim Scott, and Bernie Moreno, that applies the same wash-sale extension to digital assets.
Now read the date again. The committee’s text, as written, applies the new rule to digital assets sold after September 14, 2026. The vote happened on September 16. If the bill becomes law in that form, a sell-and-buy-back move made in October or November — done in good faith, under the rules as they exist right now — could have its tax loss disallowed retroactively, months after the sale.
What a real position looks like under this math
Say you bought a quarter of a Bitcoin last year near the top, at roughly $110,000 per coin — a cost basis of $27,500. As of October 22, Bitcoin traded around $81,739. That quarter-coin is worth about $20,435 today, a loss of $7,065.
Under today’s rules, you can sell that position, lock in the $7,065 loss, and buy the identical 0.25 BTC back immediately. If you have other capital gains this year, that loss offsets them — worth roughly $1,060 at the 15% long-term capital-gains rate. With no other gains, up to $3,000 of it comes off your ordinary income this year, and the rest carries forward to future years.
That is the deduction H.R. 10357 puts at risk for anyone who does the sell-and-buy-back move on a sale dated after September 14. The loss isn’t destroyed if it’s disallowed — it gets added to the cost basis of the Bitcoin you bought back. But it leaves this year’s return, and the tax bill you planned around it doesn’t shrink the way you expected.
Three choices if you’re sitting on a Bitcoin loss right now
There are no certainties here, only probabilities, and a tax professional who works with digital assets should be in this conversation before you act. But as of today, the choices break down to three:
One — do nothing. Keep the Bitcoin you have. Nothing about this bill touches you if you never sell.
Two — sell for the loss and wait. The 30-day window runs both directions: you can’t have bought Bitcoin in the 30 days before the sale either, and that includes an automatic recurring buy most people forget they have running. Stay out of Bitcoin for at least 31 days after the sale, and the loss holds up under today’s rules and under the bill as written. The cost is real: for a month, you don’t own the asset, and Bitcoin has made some of its sharpest multi-week moves in exactly that kind of window.
Three — sell and buy back right away. Fully legal today. But if H.R. 10357 becomes law with the September 14 date intact, a sale made after that date doing exactly this is the specific transaction the bill targets.
Why dollar stablecoins get a pass, and Bitcoin doesn’t
Read past the headline provision and there’s a carve-out: qualifying U.S. dollar stablecoins are explicitly excluded from the new wash-sale rule. The stated reasoning is simple enough — a dollar stablecoin is engineered to barely move in price, so there’s rarely a loss worth harvesting in the first place. Fair, as far as it goes.
But notice exactly who got written out of this rule and who didn’t. The token with a company behind it — an issuer who can mint more of it, freeze an account, or ask Washington for a carve-out — got the pass. The one asset in this entire conversation with no company, no issuer, and a hard-coded supply of 21 million did not. That is not a technical footnote. It is 2026 in miniature: every new stablecoin platform, every tokenized bond pilot, every “digital money” headline this year still has a man who can print more of it standing behind the product. Bitcoin is the one line item in this bill that nobody wrote an exemption for, because there is no issuer to write one to.
Is this actually becoming law? What’s changed since the vote
As of early October, Senator Lummis — who has pushed her own digital-asset tax legislation since 2025 — said she’d be surprised if anything tax-related on digital assets gets finished during the post-election lame-duck session, pointing to a Senate Finance Committee that’s reluctant to reopen the tax code so soon after last year’s tax bill. That lowers the odds this becomes law before December 31. It does not erase the risk. A bill that cleared committee 38-5, has a Senate companion, and already carries a Joint Committee on Taxation score doesn’t disappear because one senator is doubtful about the calendar — it waits for the next window. And the retroactive September 14 date stays written into the text for as long as the bill is alive.
The third tax: the one nobody mails you a form for
There’s a quieter version of this same story sitting underneath both the wash-sale fight and the new 1099-DA reporting rules, and it never shows up as a line item anywhere. Capital gains are not indexed for inflation. Say you bought half a Bitcoin in 2020 for $10,000. At today’s price, that half-coin is worth roughly $40,870 — a gain of about $30,870, taxed at 15% for about $4,630. But $10,000 in 2020 dollars takes about $12,940 today just to buy the same goods and services. A meaningful slice of that “gain” the IRS is taxing isn’t profit at all. It’s the dollar getting smaller, counted as income because the tax code was never built to tell the difference.
That is the pattern underneath every part of this story. Congress votes on whether Bitcoin gets a wash-sale break. Congress votes on which tokens get a stablecoin carve-out. Congress sets the capital-gains brackets that don’t adjust for what a dollar actually buys. On every one of those questions, somebody in Washington holds a vote and a pen. Bitcoin’s own supply — 21 million coins, a schedule written down in 2009 and never touched since — has never once been on that agenda. Wherever the truth lands in this story, it keeps landing on Bitcoin.
Want to see what a shrinking dollar and a changing tax code are quietly doing to your own retirement numbers? The free quiz at Tim Talks Finance runs the math on your real numbers, not a hypothetical: https://timtalksfinance.com/members
Related viewing: This article is built from the video that walks through the full bill, the 1099-DA blank-basis trap, wallet-by-wallet tracking, and how Bitcoin gains can reach your Social Security taxes and Medicare IRMAA two years later. Watch Congress Is Taking Away a Bitcoin Tax Break. The Date Already Passed. for the complete breakdown.
Educational commentary, not individual tax or financial advice. H.R. 10357 is not law and may change, stall, or never pass; confirm current law with a tax professional who works with digital assets before making any decision about selling, harvesting losses, or rebuying Bitcoin. Bitcoin’s price has historically moved sharply in both directions, including drawdowns of more than 70% from prior highs, and past performance is not a guarantee of future results. Do your own research and consult a qualified professional before making any financial or tax decision.
Sources: Forvis Mazars: Ways & Means Approves Digital Asset Tax Certainty Act · Unchained: House Panel Advances Crypto Tax Bill That Would Limit Certain Loss Write-Offs · CryptoSlate: Congress Wants to Make Crypto Easier to Use — and Still Collect $500 Million More in Taxes · 24/7 Wall St: A Senate Bill Would Make Small Stablecoin Purchases Tax-Free and Close Crypto’s Wash-Sale Loophole · Crypto Briefing: Cynthia Lummis Doubts a Crypto Tax Bill Will Pass This Year · Fortune: Current Price of Bitcoin for October 22, 2026 · Tim Talks Finance: Congress Is Taking Away a Bitcoin Tax Break. The Date Already Passed.